Modesty is Misogynistic

21 Feb

by Amy Wiggington 

There are unwritten rules about what women should and should not wear. Many of these rules are wrapped up in a single idea: modesty. People have been using modesty as a reason to shame women and their bodies and their lifestyles for millennia. If you don’t cover enough, you don’t deserve to be respected, it says. You don’t even respect yourself.

But no matter how many religious communities and media sources tell me otherwise, what and how much I wear is not an invitation for judgment.  It will not tell you how much I respect myself, how sexually active I am, or how religious I am.

Modesty is based on the idea that sexuality shouldn’t be expressed in public.   Thinking about or- God forbid- talking about sex is taboo and wrong.  And somehow avoiding this is entirely the responsibility of women.  If men see you as a sexual object, it’s your fault for wearing whatever it is that you have on.  Because it must be something that uses mind-control powers to cause them to forget that you are a human being, deserving of respect and dignity.

Every person feels comfortable and confident in clothes that cover a certain amount of his or her body.  This amount naturally varies between people, between seasons, and between different contexts.  The concept of modesty, however, claims that there is one level of coverage that should be maintained for everyone.  If you choose not to maintain this standard of dress, you are labeled as “slutty.” When you are disrespected, people consider it to be understandable.

I don’t understand, though.  Adding another foot of fabric to my skirt doesn’t make me more human.  Putting on a sweater doesn’t earn me respect.  I should be able to walk around town in a bikini if I want and not worry about being harassed, because I am ALIVE, I am HUMAN, I have FEELINGS, and I have inherent DIGNITY.  What I wear and why is my business and mine alone.

I saw a great Jordanian ad about this topic a few months ago (see below). It says, “Those who see you as meat without the hijab, see you as meat under the hijab.”  If someone thinks that the amount of clothes I wear should determine the amount of respect I deserve, the problem is with them.  As a society, we need to get used to the idea that we are all different and that each person should be able to choose what he or she feels comfortable in.

The concept of modesty- the idea that a certain amount of my body needs to be covered in order to be “appropriate”- needs to disappear.  If my dress gets you hot and bothered, remember that I am a person, not a sex object.

5 Responses to “Modesty is Misogynistic”

  1. Christina Crisostomo February 22, 2013 at 7:38 pm #

    Amen, Amy! Never thought about it this way. Thanks for posting!

  2. Horny Men February 24, 2013 at 3:05 am #

    Clothes send out a signal. What you wear and why is your business, but it still has an impact on the people around you. I’m sorry that you’re so aghast if men see you in a bikini or hijab and want to have sex with you. If I don’t know a girl and I see her walking around in a smoking hot bikini looking good, you can be damn sure that I’ll think about her as a “sex object.” So will every other guy with an average level of testosterone. Just seeing all that skin does indeed have a physical effect on arousal and sets off triggers that would not be set off by a hijab.

    • felinefatale June 22, 2013 at 11:35 am #

      And that’s your problem matey. You can look at someone and think they’re attractive and not that that’s ALL they are. How come no one says the same about men running around topless? Is that an invitation for me to view them as a sex object? Oh wait no, because I’m a woman and I’m not allowed to enjoy sex.

      There’s a difference between thinking someone looks attractive and totally objectifying them, and if you can’t see the difference between that, then those are your issues.

      • Edi June 28, 2013 at 3:46 pm #

        “How come no one says the same about men running around topless? Is that an invitation for me to view them as a sex object?” – in my opinion it could easily be an invitation. I do run sometimes, and if I knew that by running topless, women would perceive me as a sex object – I would do it every damn time. Because why not? I don’t lose anything and all these hypothetical women’s looks I could get would make me feel attractive.

        P.S. You are a woman and you are totally allowed to enjoy sex. We are human, it’s our nature to enjoy it.

  3. teamedwardjace June 19, 2014 at 5:58 am #

    Whether or a person wants to dress sexy or wear clothes that show clevage or more skin or more conservative garments is up to them . Seriously. I’m a feminist and equalitarian

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: